True Crime + Horror

45 of 45 Items
View
icon-grid
If There Is a Murder Yo I’ll Solve It Ceramic Coffee Mug
New If There Is a Murder Yo I’ll Solve It Ceramic Coffee Mug

$18.95

Clowns Are Funny Magnet
New Clowns Are Funny Magnet

$6.95

Killin' It Notepad
New Killin' It Notepad

$11.95

The Husband Did It Ceramic Coffee Mug
New The Husband Did It Ceramic Coffee Mug

$18.95

No You Hang Up First! Ceramic Coffee Mug
New No You Hang Up First! Ceramic Coffee Mug

$18.95

Serial Killer Birthday Card - Pick Your Month!
Serial Killer Birthday Card - Pick Your Month!

$5.95

Buy more, save more
It Was Going to Be a Very Happy Birthday Dateline Card
It Was Going to Be a Very Happy Birthday Dateline Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
Doesn't Grow up to Be a Serial Killer Card
Doesn't Grow up to Be a Serial Killer Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
100 Years of Horror Movies Trivial Pursuit Edition
100 Years of Horror Movies Trivial Pursuit Edition

$27.95

Atlas of Dark Destinations Book - Explore the World of Dark Tourism
Atlas of Dark Destinations Book - Explore the World of Dark Tourism

$30.00

Are Those Pussy Willows? Ceramic Coffee Mug
Are Those Pussy Willows? Ceramic Coffee Mug

$18.95

Yay, Serial Killer Documentaries Vinyl Sticker
Yay, Serial Killer Documentaries Vinyl Sticker

$4.95

Buy more, save more
Have a Killer Father's Day Card
Have a Killer Father's Day Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
One Year Closer to Eternal Darkness Birthday Card
One Year Closer to Eternal Darkness Birthday Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
Stop Running Away, Dipshits Card
Stop Running Away, Dipshits Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
Wanted to Make Sure You Hadn't Been Murdered Card
Wanted to Make Sure You Hadn't Been Murdered Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
I Heard There Was an Unsolved Murder in That Home Card
I Heard There Was an Unsolved Murder in That Home Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
American Serial Killers Book - The Epidemic Years 1950-2000
American Serial Killers Book - The Epidemic Years 1950-2000

$27.00

I Love You More Than True Crime Podcasts Card
I Love You More Than True Crime Podcasts Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
True Crimes and Chill Candle
True Crimes and Chill Candle

$24.95

I Serially Must Admit as a Mom You're Killing It Card
I Serially Must Admit as a Mom You're Killing It Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
Murder She Wrote Women's Crew Socks
Murder She Wrote Women's Crew Socks

$14.95

My Favorite Murder Ceramic Coffee Mug
My Favorite Murder Ceramic Coffee Mug

$18.95

It Was All So Romantic Dateline Card
It Was All So Romantic Dateline Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
Feel Better Soon Card
Feel Better Soon Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
Cleaver Bookmark
Cleaver Bookmark

$4.95

Chasing Ghosts Book - A Tour of Our Fascination with Spirits and the Supernatural
Chasing Ghosts Book - A Tour of Our Fascination with Spirits and the Supernatural

$23.00

All Work No Play Vinyl Sticker
All Work No Play Vinyl Sticker

$4.95

Buy more, save more
Gafuck Yaself Vinyl Sticker
Gafuck Yaself Vinyl Sticker

$4.95

Buy more, save more
I Hope Your Birthday Is a Scream Card
I Hope Your Birthday Is a Scream Card

$5.95

Buy more, save more
Only Murders in the Building Vinyl Sticker
Only Murders in the Building Vinyl Sticker

$4.95

Buy more, save more
I’m a Screamer Vinyl Sticker
I’m a Screamer Vinyl Sticker

$4.95

Buy more, save more
Camp Crystal Lake T-Shirt
Camp Crystal Lake T-Shirt

Sale $29.99$34.95

The Shining Dice Set
The Shining Dice Set

Sale $7.99$9.95

The Big Book of Ghost Stories
The Big Book of Ghost Stories

Sale $24.99$28.95

The 10 Greatest Conspiracies of All Time Book
The 10 Greatest Conspiracies of All Time Book

Sale $11.99$15.95

The Lost Art of Letter Writing Dateline Card
The Lost Art of Letter Writing Dateline Card

Sale $4.99$5.95

Buy more, save more
The O.G. Murderino Vinyl Sticker
The O.G. Murderino Vinyl Sticker

Sale $3.99$4.95

Buy more, save more
Cabot Cove Vinyl Sticker
Cabot Cove Vinyl Sticker

Sale $3.99$4.95

Buy more, save more
Spooky X-Files Card
Spooky X-Files Card

Sale $4.99$5.95

Buy more, save more
Murder She Wrote Vinyl Sticker
Murder She Wrote Vinyl Sticker

Sale $3.99$4.95

Buy more, save more
All of the Possible Ways I Could Get Murdered Card
Be back soon! All of the Possible Ways I Could Get Murdered Card

$5.95

I’d Make a True Crime Podcast With You Card
Be back soon! I’d Make a True Crime Podcast With You Card

$5.95

Prison Ramen Cookbook - Recipes and Stories From Behind Bars
Be back soon! Prison Ramen Cookbook - Recipes and Stories From Behind Bars

$13.95

199 Cemeteries to See Before You Die Book
Be back soon! 199 Cemeteries to See Before You Die Book

$28.00

True Crime + Horror

Calling all murderinos! If you have a psychotic obsession with true crime podcasts, true crime documentaries and all things horror, this collection of unique gifts is for you. From serial killer books to horror movie greeting cards, shop AlwaysFits.com for unique gifts inspired by your favorite murders and murderers.